In Search of Meaning

November 27, 2008

Racism immunity?

I have always thought that the fact that I was growing up in an all-white society really gave me a rather limited perspective on life and was sort of envious of people that were born in more culturally diverse societies. But about a month ago at the interculturalist congress and Granada, Spain, while sharing with a young American lady about various topics that had to do with racism, I have realized that perhaps not all was bad about my situation and that I have actually inherited something beautiful – the state of being colour blind. Let me explain.

You see, I grew up in the country that does not exist anymore: Yugoslavia. We were brought up in a discourse that the West, with it’s capitalist exploitation of people, was bad. And we were also taught that the East, with it’s communist dictatorship and ignorance to basic human rights, was also bad. We were taught that neither of the two extremes of the Cold War were of any good and that the world needed the third way. The opportunity for the third way was seen in the Non-Aligned movement that basically consisted of the Third World countries, and Yugoslavia, the only member from Europe. So the heroes that were presented to us were in general, along with Tito, of Asian and African origin, like Gandhi, Nehru, Naser, Kaunda, Mandela… We were taught to respect these people and race did not play any role AT ALL. In fact, white race was, in general, seen as aggressive and non-white as oppressed freedom fighters and a new hope for humanity.

Yet another fact was that we had no first-hand relations with non-white individuals at all. In fact NOBODY had any experience and there was no heritage in this regard whatsoever. Blank page. Nothing happened in the past. No stories, no biases, nothing. So, while talking to this young American lady, who had to, while growing up in the U.S., dig her way through all the cultural prejudices, personal and family stories, discourses of all sort of kinds, in order to build her own relationship (which will, no matter what she does, never be only her own, it will never be pure), I realized how lucky I really was. Whenever this white American lady sees an, say, African American on the street, so many associations automatically jump up, so many layers get stimulated, so many lenses pop up in her mind, blurring and biasing her image, on perhaps a very subtle and weak lever, but nevertheless it is there. This is at least how she has explained to me.

Listening to her I realized that actually my first contact with a non-white person was when I found myself, at age 17, in Africa on my escape from life. And there was no background to it, no pre-planted seeds, no attitudes, no preconceive ideas, just a simple and straight interaction with another human being. The colour of skin mattered just as much as the colour of hair. Nothing. On the conscious level at least.

And to this day I cannot find anything else in regard to my perception of diversity of the colour of the human skin. Seems like my relation to the question of “other races” started out of nothing and did not evolve in any weird ways. I feel like a happy colour blind person. So, as weird as this dead country of Yugoslavia was, I am actually really happy I was born here.

And, speaking of Yugoslavia, here’s a video of my ex-schoolmate with his artistic name Magnifico, about Yugoslavia – The Land of Champions. ;-) It is a nostalgic account of the times lost, with using the iconography of spaghetti western films (and some kung-fu movies too) that we all grew up watching and adoring, and with strictly sticking to the macho Balkan English accent. Enjoy!


17 Comments »

  1. Love the video. Too bad there weren’t more lyrics telling more of a story.

    The whole racism thing is a tricky one. I’ve had very good experiences with some groups and very bad with others. I have to keep reminding myself that it’s the culture, not the race.

    One thing that travel has taught me is that we are all basically the same and bad people are also considered bad, by people of their own race.

    In the near future, I’ll be writing on my blog about my experiences with African Americans in the US and how racism is really hurting that country. Hopefully Obama will help dispel a lot of the ill will the ignorant have over there.

    Comment by razzbuffnik — November 28, 2008 @ 9:05 am

  2. Hi,

    I’m French and grew up in France, with many immigrants for several generations, and our past as a colonialist. And while I grew up in a family that wanted to be tolerant and open, strangely enough the only coloured people I was in contact with were the poor ones that my parents helped ; the only ones I saw on TV were the poor ones, the illegal immigrants, the one arrested by the police and so forth. And this is typical of a good part of the French society. Not racist in thory, but preferring the whites in the facts, in subtle way, unconsciously.

    We won’t fight racism by saying we should all love each other and that the colour doesn’t matter while keeping seeing on TV only white people shown in a good way and coloured people in riots, bomb attacks etc, implementing positive discrimination, thinking it’s absolutely amazing to have a black man to present the main news, arguing in the national assembly whether colonialism should be presented as something positive or negative in school books, etc.

    I have often wondered about the point of history and what we call “devoir de mémoire” in French, which means the duty or obligation to remember and commemorate. If we could delete from all books everything about colonialism, slavery etc, and erase it from people’s memories too, and only have the positive exemples, wouldn’t things be better of?

    Of course we cannot change our books and memories, however we can decide not to focus on colonialism, slavery etc when talking to our kids, students, friends etc., but concentrate on positive icons ands facts.

    In he book “Blink” by M. Gladwell, I read about an experiment that really stroke me. People were presented a list of words and pictures the one after the other and had to decide between “good” and “bad”; than the same for “black” and “white”. For the next series, people had to decide between “good and black”, or “bad and white”. And here; the time it took for them to choose in which category to put each word or image was much longer (in milliseconds, but still). And yet, none of them were racists. The second part of the experiment was the most interesting I think. They wanted to find out how to change this. Even when people knew what the test was about, and told themselves they didn’t want to make a difference, that black people are as good as the whites etc., the results were the same. Only when people were presented with pictures of people like M. Luther King, Neru, Mandela, Gandhi etc just before the test did they manage better. Oh, by the way, part of the participants were coloured people and had the same results as the whites…

    Comment by Ludo et Anne-Claire — November 28, 2008 @ 11:41 am

  3. That video is HILARIOUS and gloriously cheesy. (Flying guitar!) Your friend has a beautifully deep voice. I actually like the song and it’s well-produced. I was more surprised that it was in English, but it’s totally ok that I can understand it.

    I :heart: mariachi homages!

    Comment by Hayden Tompkins — November 28, 2008 @ 3:20 pm

  4. 1. I really enjoy your writing style.
    2. I’m SO overjoyed that my kids will grow up with an African American as the first president they remember. Despite the burden this has been on our country, I look at my grandparent, parents, and my generation as pointing toward real progress. Of all the pitfalls my kids will face in life, I’m hopeful that skin color won’t be one of them.
    3. Did I mention you write good? ;-)
    4. Razz – unfortunately, I think my country has a fixed amount of ignorance to direct at *something.* If it isn’t the blacks, it will be the gays. If not the gays, then the wealthy. It is fading with time (thankfully), but we’re so used to our battles that even the ignorant seem destined to take their turn on the whipping post. I hope that doesn’t happen.

    Comment by happyjames — November 28, 2008 @ 10:11 pm

  5. Robert — This was an interesting perspective. I think that growing up outside of a national history of racism and slavery has to be freeing.

    One thing I’ve been thinking about in regards to the election of Obama, the US’s huge stab against racism, (which is a wonderful, wonderful thing on so many levels): I wonder if the outcome would have been different if he had been the son of an US-born black person, an African-American, and an US-born white person? This would have been a very different situation, one with all the weight of our history. I wonder if it would have been possible. Just a thought. It doesn’t detract from the momentousness, the joyousness of Barack Obama’s election, but I think it needs noting.

    Comment by Jennifer — November 29, 2008 @ 6:36 am

  6. Razz – glad you loved the video. I can’t wait for your posts on racism, please, get going and write it down, mate, don’t just play with your camera… :-D

    Anne-Claire – strong point you are making here. I guess the main discourse of our societies is still the image of the big white imperialist brother, lovingly helping primitive non-white children, gradually promoting them towards intelligence and civilisation.

    Hayden – I am so happy you got the point of Magnifico’s video. This is the way he does things, playing around with and exploring different social phenomena (machismo, primitivism, intellectualism, non-tolerance, crime, sex…) and his main mean of expression is pure kitsch. If you have time, have a look at his video of the song Silvia (a tribute to French actress Sylvia Kristel, the one from Emanuelle movies, films that drove kids of our age, back than, nuts. And to many wet dreams. ;-) ). The song is in Slovene, but the video is an utter genius and an anthology of these French disco 70′, with Magnifico’s every single move and gesture impersonating these flashy disco stars: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S703K1esI3M&feature=related . I just LOVE IT.

    Happyjames – thanks, my friend. And I LOVE your comments.

    Jennifer – no matter how much I try, I can’t understand the difference it would make if Obama’s father was an African-American. And I am VERY interested to understand, so would you be willing to explain your thoughts. Please.

    Comment by Robert — November 29, 2008 @ 1:32 pm

  7. Hmmm. I am not sure how I would explain, except that I think there are a few differences, in Obama’s own life experiences and in the general difference in cultural baggage. Take a look at this wikipedia article on African immigrants versus Black Americans (as the article calls them — I realize that I am using ambiguous terms). Maybe that will explain it better than I can. My point is that racism in the US goes beyond skin color, but is part of a larger social perception and cultural experience. I’ve also been up since 4:00 a.m, but wanted to respond. Hope it is coherent.

    Comment by Jennifer — November 29, 2008 @ 4:40 pm

  8. Jennifer – thanks for this explanation, it does clarify things for me a bit…

    Comment by Robert — December 1, 2008 @ 6:35 pm

  9. I truly enjoyed reading this. I am a person of color, but do not consider myself to be African-American. I am not from Africa. My husband is also a person of color. He is from another country…(Not Africa) and so he too is not “African American”. We have got so many cultures mixed up within our families that both our exteriors belie the types of blood that flow through our interior veins. Obama? He is truly an African-American. He is: “The real thing”. Love and Peace to you and yours- Thanks for sharing….-Nards

    Comment by Nards — December 4, 2008 @ 6:48 pm

  10. “I can’t wait for your posts on racism”

    Done.

    Comment by razzbuffnik — December 5, 2008 @ 1:37 pm

  11. Anne-Claire’s comment on memory triggered some thoughts.
    As a historian those issues of commemoration interest me. It sometimes feels being caught in the past. Having big national commemoration ceremonies is supposed to “never forget”, But what is it that you don’t want to forget? And it almost feels ‘cheap’ to have silence for 2 minutes once a year (which is done in the Netherlands on the 4th of May, the day before Dutch Liberation Day on the 5th of May) and then go back to our daily business.
    Erasing the colonial or any past is not possible indeed, but should never be wished for either. Our past will always be a part of us, not talking about certain parts of it is not the solution. But what is the way to deal with the so-called ‘black pages’ of our history, to come to terms with them? I don’t mean to just accept it and move on. That’s close to forgetting it. What I look for is almost like embracing it, to be able to acknowledge what happened, see the good and bad, realising that there is good and bad in everyone of us. But I still don’t know how this can be done concretely. And if this makes any difference to commemorate once a year and move on… I’m rambling…Anyone who can help here?

    Comment by Anne-Claire — December 5, 2008 @ 6:20 pm

  12. Nards – welcome. Colours, cultures, nationalities…, it is so sad that these things have such a heavy symbolic meaning and that so much pain gets caused by these differences being pointed out and labelled over and over again.

    Razz – here I go to read it…

    Anne-Claire – welcome back! Interesting points you are making here. I always wonder about the questions of accepting and/or forgetting, embracing or denying… Especially I find intriguing the idea of the collective responsibility, memory, even guilt. We had a good dialogue process on this topic last year in Berlin on Young Sietar Congress and I am still sometimes thinking about all the various aspects that came up.

    Comment by Robert — December 9, 2008 @ 11:43 pm

  13. We are different in many ways. I grew up in a country where race was in your face 24/7 and you grew up in a “colour blind” society. But we are the same in so many ways. Color makes no sense. It only makes sense when we see it through the eyes of others.

    Another great post mate.

    Comment by angryafrican — December 12, 2008 @ 4:10 pm

  14. Am with AA on this one possibly due to the fact that we hail from the same country – colour is nothing unless it is made to be in order to boost another. Incredible post!

    Comment by SanityFound — December 18, 2008 @ 1:16 pm

  15. AA & Sanity – yes, it is really only the matter of interpretation, you know, society teaching us that some physical attributes mean something more existential: coloured skin and perhaps blond hair, but it is really just a social construction, nothing else. A couple of thousand years ago it was the shape of the nose, for istance… And when, many years back, I found myself in some villages in Africa, children ran away in horror, saying that I was from the moon (because of my bright colour eyes) and others mocking me that I was a monkey (because of my hairy legs). So…

    Comment by Robert — December 18, 2008 @ 8:16 pm

  16. Yesterday some relatives were talking about someone in a TV programme who was called “Moise”, and who happens to be tanned, and they were saying he must be an Arab (I was closed to writing “that must be an Arabe”. That shows how it felt from the tone they used). As I am pretty fed up with their attitude towards colored people, I turned to them and said that Moise is actually a Jewish name, hoping to show that they cannot judge on appearance. And you know what they asked me then? “How do Jewish people look then? It’s their hooked nose, isn’t it?” I crumbled and felt desperate…

    Comment by Ludo et Anne-Claire — December 18, 2008 @ 10:48 pm

  17. ACC – I would feel desperate too. And a bit violent, I guess.

    Comment by Robert — December 19, 2008 @ 9:40 pm


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

Blog at WordPress.com.